![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhiT831R0DhM8JKEKsPPM24NfkxHe5-vLo7PWuO7qXTyVxnd7aRNaLEITdwAyC_d7NqgwB7l-jXqfFi5zR72SdR3STlTlfIva5U7AtXhGKmIXykxPM_Tmr4Aw_qebjBkm4FDc0_Vynib-LrfJbTrTTFOIkRFbW6gHGJtn_XWoCoYAPDQN9pXw0/s320/guardian_small.jpg)
I occasionally hear people assert, as if a truism, that the web is a much more visual medium than text. I don't think it is. In fact the opposite is often true if you compare two versions of the same document. For example, here's a story from a recent issue of The Guardian newspaper.
The story (about the growth in music downloads) is illustrated by a graph comparing the years 2005 and 2006 in different countries, and also comparing mobile and online downloads. It is also decorated by images of a band, some people dancing in test tubes, and someone singing.
But compare with the online version. No images (except a portrait of the journalist we didn't see in the paper version), no graph (surely that contains a key message, even if the pictures don't. And the story is surrounded by navigation - links enticing you to stop reading this story and go somewhere else.
The story (about the growth in music downloads) is illustrated by a graph comparing the years 2005 and 2006 in different countries, and also comparing mobile and online downloads. It is also decorated by images of a band, some people dancing in test tubes, and someone singing.
But compare with the online version. No images (except a portrait of the journalist we didn't see in the paper version), no graph (surely that contains a key message, even if the pictures don't. And the story is surrounded by navigation - links enticing you to stop reading this story and go somewhere else.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEh8NSRa7EqLgXKxwDuN0vlRiMUAMa68zTJVfguPnHeRBoueaaLcEi6dIVby_BG9bLf9EEp_BSZbcoHZa06Xb3ZbiP-aBfR3v3lJzm7WwUoD6-SJZtj_QkwhJP2_m-Ux6bf-qnSsSG8meQd3NWQahg22gdDqeCUcwVnlnPqlUlRz2ZtcKPPxHLc/s320/guardianweb_small.jpg)
On another matter, the pictures in the paper are a veritable semiotic feast: what are the fascist-looking symbols in front of the band? have the test-tube ladies escaped from a story about cloning? and I love the singer's Remembrance Day poppy. Nothing is captioned so we'll never know the explanation.